Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

News

Council doesnt deny Head’s appointment was rigged

Published

on

headteacher1THE APPOINTMENT of a head teacher to a Pembrokeshire school was ‘rigged’ to favour one candidate. That is the allegation that has been made to The Pembrokeshire Herald by a member of the panel for the selection of a head teacher for Ysgol Gelli Aur/ Golden Grove School in Pembroke. Pembroke Town Councillor, Mel Phillips told The Herald: “After the former head teacher of Gelli Aur, Les Johnson announced his intention to retire, the Council provided a shortlist of two candidates – Andrew Williams, who formerly taught at Broad aven School and a teacher from Brynconin School. Curiously, I had been told by a friend that Mr Williams would be the new head teacher, even before the job had been advertised as vacant.”

Mel explained that she was puzzled as to shortlist’s brevity and challenged the ‘adviser’ appointed by the Council to assist the Governors in selecting a head teacher as to why that was the case. The adviser, Sue Painter, told selection panel members that the post had been advertised in the Times Education Supplement (TES). Melanie Phillips expressed dissatisfaction at the shortlist’s length and checked with the TES whether an advertisement had been placed. Her enquiries revealed that was not the case and the selection panel demanded it was done properly and in accordance with the regulations governing the appointment of head teachers. After the post had been advertised, a further shortlist was produced. The second shortlist contained only three names: the original two candidates and a Mr Condon from Angle School.

The panel interviewed all of the candidates and at a meeting held at the County Archives, Haverfordwest, were unanimous in considering that the teacher from Brynconin School had performed the best in interview and was the best candidate for the job. Mel Phillips told The Herald: “Sue Painter then intervened and told the selection panel that there were ‘issues’ about the panel’s choice. “When we asked why his name had been put forward, we were told – ‘We didn’t expect him to get this far’.” However, Mel told us, when panel members asked what the issues were Sue Painter refused to say and told panel members it was a confidential matter. “Well, as you can guess, that left us hanging. We asked whether allegations had been made against him, but she would only answer it was ‘confidential’. That left us all hanging, inviting us to draw the worst of adverse conclusions.

“It stank then and it stinks now, Jon. I quickly concluded that the whole process was a stitch up from start to end and that whatever the allegations were they could not be that serious as the candidate was still teaching at another school. However, such was the doubt that Sue Painter had sown that panel members decided to reconsider their decision. “Two of us on the panel, me and Hywel Edwards, walked out in protest. In our absence, Mr Williams was appointed.” Mel explained how distressed she was by the events: “I tell you, I could not sleep. That poor man had been so badly served and so let down. He was clearly the best candidate for the job and I believe he would have been a terrific head teacher at our school. After a couple of days fretting, I had to phone him him and put him in the picture as to what had happened.

I assured him that we had all concluded he was the best candidate for the head teacher’s post and it was only the intervention of Sue Painter right at the end of the process that prevented his appointment. “In fact that there was NO issue regarding the panel’s choice. He has since been appointed to the head teacher’s post at another school.” The events have left Mel with a sour conclusion: “This whole thing was a stitch up from start to end. The best candidate was not appointed, the Council had clearly decided who was going to get the job and the so-called ‘adviser’ was simply there to make sure it got its way.”

The Herald put Mel’s detailed account to the Council as a series of bullet points and asked for a response from the Head of Education, Kate Evans-Hughes. The Herald made it clear that the inference to be drawn from Mel Phillips’s account was that the process had been rigged to favour one candidate over others. The Council DID NOT deny Mel Phillips’s account was truthful or accurate. Instead a spokesperson told The Herald: “The Staffing of Maintained Schools Regulations (Wales) clearly defines the recruitment process to be followed in the case of Head Teachers, with the governing body having responsibility for selection decisions and the Local Authority acting as an ‘adviser’. “This is the role the Authority played in this particular case.” No allegation of wrongdoing is made against the successful candidate and current head teacher at Golden Grove in relation to the selection process. However, the incident highlights concerns about further appointments to head teacher positions made by the local authority since 2012.

 

1 Comment

1 Comment

  1. Tomos

    December 31, 2015 at 1:30 pm

    It stinks but will the council investigate itself ? will the Police care? nah, doubt it, it’s just the way things are done in the back of beyond where it’s great to be a big fish in a little muddy pond 🙁

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News

Starmer faces Commons showdown over Mandelson vetting row

Published

on

PRIME MINISTER ACCUSED OF MISLEADING PARLIAMENT OVER AMBASSADOR APPOINTMENT

SIR KEIR STARMER is facing a Commons vote over whether he should be investigated for allegedly misleading Parliament about the vetting of Lord Mandelson.

MPs are due to debate on Tuesday whether the Prime Minister should be referred to the powerful Commons Privileges Committee, which investigates claims that MPs have broken parliamentary rules.

The row centres on Sir Keir’s statements that “full due process” was followed when Lord Mandelson was appointed as Britain’s ambassador to the United States, and that there had been “no pressure whatsoever” on Foreign Office officials involved in the process.

Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle has agreed to allow the debate after requests from a number of MPs, including Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch. He stressed that his decision did not amount to a judgment on whether the Prime Minister had done anything wrong.

Lord Mandelson was later sacked from the Washington post following renewed scrutiny of his friendship with convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.

The appointment has since become a major political headache for Sir Keir, with questions over whether the vetting process was rushed and whether officials were put under pressure to approve the appointment.

Sir Olly Robbins, the former senior civil servant at the Foreign Office, told MPs last week that there had been “constant pressure”, although he said it did not affect his decision to approve Lord Mandelson’s security clearance.

Sir Keir has denied misleading Parliament and has sought to draw a distinction between improper pressure and the ordinary pressure of government to get things done quickly.

Downing Street dismissed the move as “a desperate political stunt by the Conservative Party” ahead of the May elections.

A No 10 spokesperson said the Government was already co-operating with parliamentary processes looking into Lord Mandelson’s appointment, adding that the Conservatives had “no answers on the cost of living or the NHS”.

Mrs Badenoch accused Sir Keir of misleading Parliament “multiple times” and urged Labour MPs to “look into their consciences” before voting.

The Liberal Democrats, Reform UK and the Greens have also indicated support for an inquiry.

However, Labour’s large Commons majority means the motion is unlikely to pass unless a significant number of Labour MPs rebel or abstain.

If the matter is referred to the Privileges Committee, it could examine whether Sir Keir knowingly misled MPs or failed to correct the record quickly enough.

The Ministerial Code states that ministers who knowingly mislead Parliament are expected to resign, while inadvertent errors should be corrected at the earliest opportunity.

 

Continue Reading

Community

Haverfordwest chip shop targeted by youths in stone-throwing incident

Published

on

A HAVERFORDWEST fish and chip shop has been left with a hefty repair bill after a group of youths allegedly targeted the premises in a late-night incident.

Coronation Chippy said it was attacked on Saturday (Apr 26), when a “bunch of kids” spent around 15 minutes throwing stones at the shop’s windows and doors. The business reported that the glass canopy at the front of the shop was smashed during the incident, leaving debris scattered outside.

In a social media post, the owners described the damage as costing “£1000s of pounds” and said the incident had caused distress not only to staff but also to neighbouring businesses.

They said: “Unfortunately, our business was a target to thugs yesterday. A bunch of kids with nothing better to do and even less respect for others decided to spend 15 minutes throwing stones at the windows and doors of the shop. This resulted in the glass canopy that covers the shop being smashed.”

Dyfed-Powys Police attended the scene, with the business thanking officers for their “prompt response and support.” Crews from Haverfordwest Fire Station were also called to make the area safe by removing broken glass.

The shop also praised local contractor Dave Hughes of W.B Griffiths & Son Ltd for assisting with urgent repairs, along with neighbours who offered support in the aftermath.

The owners added: “The result of what these kids think of as ‘fun’ has resulted in £1000s of pounds of damage, the involvement of multiple services and upset so many.”

Police have not yet confirmed whether any arrests have been made.

Anyone with information about the incident is urged to contact Dyfed-Powys Police.

 

Continue Reading

News

Most Welsh voters say King’s US visit will make little difference

Published

on

A NEW poll of Welsh voters suggests most people believe King Charles’s official state visit to the United States is unlikely to change US policy towards the UK.

The YouGov polling, carried out in Wales, found that 56% of respondents thought the visit would not make much difference.

A further 24% believed it would improve US policy towards the UK, with 6% saying it would improve it a lot and 18% saying it would improve it a little.

Only 5% thought the visit would make matters worse, while 16% said they did not know.

The findings suggest that while there is some public belief that the monarchy can still play a diplomatic role, most people in Wales appear unconvinced that a state visit alone will significantly shift American policy.

MPs drinking before late-night votes

The same polling also found strong opposition in Wales to MPs drinking alcohol on evenings when they are later expected to vote in Parliament.

Asked whether it was acceptable for MPs to drink alcohol on evenings where late-night votes are due to take place, 60% said it was completely unacceptable.

A further 18% said it was somewhat unacceptable, meaning almost eight in ten respondents opposed the practice.

Only 14% said it was acceptable, with 2% saying it was completely acceptable and 12% saying it was somewhat acceptable.

The findings come amid continuing public concern over standards in Westminster and the conduct of elected representatives.

Grey squirrel fertility plan divides opinion

The poll also showed Welsh voters are divided over proposals to make grey squirrels infertile as a way of reducing their population.

A total of 39% said they would support such a programme, with 14% strongly supporting it and 25% somewhat supporting it.

However, 36% said they were opposed, including 22% who somewhat opposed it and 14% who strongly opposed it.

A quarter of respondents said they did not know.

The idea of controlling grey squirrel numbers has been discussed for years because of the impact the species has on native red squirrels and woodland habitats.

But the Welsh polling suggests the public remains split over whether fertility control is the right way to deal with the issue.

 

Continue Reading

Local Government3 hours ago

Council pays tribute to long-serving councillor Brian Hall

PEMBROKESHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL has paid tribute to long-serving Pembroke Dock Market councillor Brian Hall, following his death. Cllr Hall first...

Sport23 hours ago

Bluebirds reach European play-off final after penalty drama in Barry

Haverfordwest County beat Barry Town United 3-1 on spot-kicks after 1-1 draw at Jenner Park HAVERFORDWEST COUNTY are one win...

News2 days ago

Barley Saturday brings bumper crowds to Cardigan

CROWDS lined the streets of Cardigan on Saturday (Apr 25) as Barley Saturday once again brought the town centre to...

Community2 days ago

Freshwater West memorial honours crews lost in wartime tragedy

VETERANS, standard bearers and civic representatives gathered at Freshwater West on Saturday (Apr 25) for a moving service of remembrance...

News2 days ago

Haverfordwest Hemp hustings to explore role in Wales’ future economy

Debate at Haverhub to link agriculture, sustainability and Senedd election issues A UNIQUE political and environmental debate is set to...

News3 days ago

Parties use postcode-targeted social media adverts in Senedd campaign

LABOUR has spent more than twice as much as any other Welsh political party on Facebook and Instagram advertising in...

News3 days ago

Pressure builds as Labour ducks farming hustings

NOT one of Labour’s seven list candidates for the Ceredigion Penfro seat turned up for farming hustings in either Pembrokeshire...

News4 days ago

Kemi Badenoch warns over loss of industry during Valero visit

Conservative leader says Wales cannot afford to lose more strategic jobs as she attacks Reform and backs Darren Millar KEMI...

News4 days ago

Waiting lists fall for ninth month — but cancer, A&E and ambulance pressures grow

Labour points to “real progress” on treatment backlogs as surgeons and Conservatives warn the next Welsh Government still faces a...

Crime4 days ago

Man on trial over historic sex offence allegations

Pembroke Dock defendant faces charges spanning from 1984 to 2008 A MAN from Pembroke Dock is standing trial at Swansea...

Popular This Week